Get Your
Quote Now!
 
Enter Your Zip Code to Get
Auto Insurance Web Quote
 

Butler, IN Car Insurance Rates

Butler, IN Car Insurance Rates

Looking for low cost auto insurance in your town? Either fill out the quote form above or call one of your local agents below. The quote form will allow you to compare rates more quickly in your zip code. If you need assistance please contact us and we will help you find savings for your unique auto situation.

Contact Company Website
Kathy Bailey
(260) 868-2680
Welker Associates Insurance
239 S Broadway St
Butler, IN
(260) 868-2680 Welker Associates Insurance
239 S Broadway St
Butler, IN
Roger Strup
(419) 298-2335
Strup Insurance Incorporated
153 N Michigan Ave
Edgerton, IN
Robert Spragg
(419) 298-2812
Dietsch Insurance Incorporated
1774 State Route 49
Edgerton, IN
Ed Lehman
(419) 298-2212
Lehman Insurance
134 W Indiana St
Edgerton, IN
(419) 272-2888 Best Insurance & Financial Services
105 N Michigan St
Edon, IN
(419) 298-2212 Lehman Insurance Agency
134 E Indiana St
Edgerton, IN
(419) 542-9600 American Family Insurance- Greg A Newton Agency
164 E High St
Hicksville, IN
http://www.amfam.com/agen...
Herb Horrom
(260) 925-4766
Brown & Brown Insurance
309 S Jackson St
Auburn, IN
http://www.brownandbrowni...
Randy Koeppe
(260) 488-2636
Carper-Koeppe Insurance
7715 S Wayne St
Hamilton, IN
Bret Brown
(260) 837-5871
Le & Bret Brown Insurance
515 N Wayne St
Waterloo, IN
Charles G Howard
(260) 488-2380
Howard Insurance
3925 E Bellefontaine Rd
Hamilton, IN
(260) 488-2380 Howard Insurance
3925 E Bellefontaine Rd
Hamilton, IN
Timothy D Baker
(260) 837-7601
Baker Insurance
250 N Wayne St
Waterloo, IN
(419) 542-8548 Scranton Insurance
5449 State Route 49
Hicksville, IN
http://www.grangeinsuranc...
Earl Crall
(419) 542-8548
Scranton Insurance
5449 State Route 49
Hicksville, IN
(260) 837-7601 Baker Insurance Agency
250 Widney
Waterloo, IN
http://www.pekininsurance...
(260) 665-6177 American Family Insurance- Julie A Burrell-Marturello Agency
1006 N Wayne St Ste A
Angola, IN
http://www.amfam.com/agen...
(260) 925-5376 Insurance & Financial Services
3508 Franklin Dr
Auburn, IN
(419) 636-2540 Allstate Insurance Companies
1111 W High St
Bryan, IN
http://agent.allstate.com...
(260) 925-5088 Roarks Insurance Services Incorporated
1710 N Main St
Auburn, IN
Jan Snyder
(419) 272-3116
New York Life Insurance Company
116 N Michigan St
Edon, IN
http://newyorklife.com/
Donna M Boseker
(260) 925-4314
Donavan Insurance Service
102 E 6th St
Auburn, IN
http://donavanins.com/
Dan Nagel
(260) 927-1690
Nagel Insurance
501 S Main St
Auburn, IN
Stanley Washler
(260) 925-2510
Auburn Insurance Center Incorporated
106 N Cedar St
Auburn, IN
(260) 925-2510 Auburn Insurance Center
106 N Cedar St
Auburn, IN
Jim Friend
(260) 925-4314
Donavan Insurance Service
102 E 6th St
Auburn, IN
Kerry Sibery
(260) 925-1434
Insurance & Financial Service
302 N Jackson St
Auburn, IN
Kevin Sibery
(260) 925-1434
Insurance & Financial Service
302 N Jackson St
Auburn, IN
(260) 925-1434 Insurance & Financial Services
302 N Jackson St
Auburn, IN
Maury Winkler
(260) 925-8309
Peoples Insurance Agency
212 W 7th St
Auburn, IN
Eric Ward
(260) 925-4766
Brown & Brown Insurance
309 S Jackson St
Auburn, IN
Fred Brown
(260) 925-4766
Brown & Brown Insurance
309 S Jackson St
Auburn, IN
http://brownandbrowninsur...
James L Hefty
(260) 925-1717
State Farm Insurance
367 W 7th St
Auburn, IN
http://statefarm.com/
Dick Penland
(260) 925-2668
DE Kalb Farm Mutual Insurance
525 Michigan Ave
Auburn, IN
Dave Baughman
(260) 925-2668
DE Kalb Farm Mutual Insurance
525 Michigan Ave
Auburn, IN
(260) 925-2668 Dekalb Farm Mutual Insurance Company
525 Michigan Ave
Auburn, IN
Greg Newton
(419) 542-9600
American Family Insurance
164 E High St
Hicksville, IN
http://amfam.com/
Patricia King
(419) 542-7954
King Kreg Insurance Incorporated
136 E High St
Hicksville, IN
Greg Collins
(419) 542-7313
Greg Collins Insurance
105 E High St
Hicksville, IN
Joyce A Hefty
(260) 925-1717
State Farm Insurance
367 W 7th St
Auburn, IN
Ken Cline
(419) 542-7758
Cline-Armstrong Insurance Incorporated
501 W High St
Hicksville, IN
Paul King
(419) 542-7954
King Kreg Insurance Incorporated
136 E High St
Hicksville, IN
(260) 925-0100 Farmers Insurance Group
1041 W 7th St
Auburn, IN
http://www.farmers.com/
Cherie Malcolm
(260) 925-8400
American Family Insurance
1016 W 7th St Ste 125
Auburn, IN
(260) 665-3784 Lewis Insurance Agency
610 S Wayne St
Hamilton, IN
(260) 665-3149 Farm Bureau Insurance
1480 W Maumee St
Angola, IN
http://www.infarmbureau.c...
Marland Bosse
(260) 665-7257
Bosse Insurance
105 W Maumee St # A
Angola, IN
http://bosseinsurance.com...
Richard Erman
(260) 665-1963
Erman Insurance
1900 Westwood Dr
Angola, IN
http://www.alliedinsuranc...
(260) 665-2746 State Farm Insurance
406 W Maumee St
Angola, IN
http://www.statefarm.com/
Jack Collins
(419) 636-7772
Nationwide Insurance
1210 W High St
Bryan, IN
http://www.nationwide.com...
(419) 633-3000 Shirkey Insurance & Investment
Po Box 296
Edon, IN
Jon D Michael
(419) 636-6761
Jon D Michael Insurance
1219 W High St
Bryan, IN
http://michael-insurance....
(260) 627-2709 Sauder Richard E Insurance
11307 Shoreline Dr
Leo, IN
Richard Slaybaugh
(260) 925-4214
Farm Bureau Insurance
506 S Grandstaff Dr
Auburn, IN
Gary Thornton
(419) 636-2540
Allstate Insurance Company
1111 W High St
Bryan, IN
Donald Roe
(260) 665-9537
Croxton & Roe Insurance Service
418 N Wayne St
Angola, IN
Tony Culver
(260) 665-9537
Croxton & Roe Insurance Service
418 N Wayne St
Angola, IN
Jeff Elliott
(260) 665-9193
Insurance Marketplace
210 W Maumee St
Angola, IN
Phil Roe
(260) 665-9537
Croxton & Roe Insurance Service
418 N Wayne St
Angola, IN

 
Customers say...
I spoke with my agent from ***** who said I probably wouldn't save much, so instead, I went straight home after picking up the kids from school, jumped on to AutoInsuranceWeb.com, and in a few short minutes, found that I could save about $40 a month by switching insurance companies. I think I'm going to save a few $1,000 dollars over the next few years. Gosh! My agent is terrible. I owe you a big one :)

Kimara