Looking for low cost auto insurance in your town? Either fill out the quote form above or call one of your local agents below. The quote form will allow you to compare rates more quickly in your zip code. If you need assistance please contact us and we will help you find savings for your unique auto situation.
| Contact |
Company |
Website |
| (765) 529-4441 |
American Family Insurance- Michael A Meek Agency
520 S Main St
New Castle, IN |
http://www.amfam.com/agen... |
| (765) 529-3030 |
Associated Agencies Insurance
1700 S Memorial Dr
New Castle, IN |
|
Jacqueline Ashby
(765) 529-0707 |
Allstate Insurance Company
1824 Bundy Ave
New Castle, IN |
http://agent.allstate.com... |
Doug Meier
(765) 529-8755 |
State Farm Insurance
318 Parkview Dr
New Castle, IN |
http://www.statefarm.com/ |
| (765) 529-6400 |
Pfenninger Insurance Agency
1220 Broad St
New Castle, IN |
http://www.pfenningeragen... |
Michael A Meek
(765) 529-4441 |
American Family Insurance
520 S Main St
New Castle, IN |
http://amfam.com/ |
Steve Pfenninger
(765) 529-6400 |
Pfenninger Insurance
1220 Broad St
New Castle, IN |
http://www.pfenningeragen... |
Fred Donnell
(765) 529-2751 |
State Farm Insurance
210 S Main St
New Castle, IN |
http://statefarm.com/ |
Duane Clemens
(765) 529-5420 |
Clemens Insurance & Financial
1202 Vine St
New Castle, IN |
|
Chris Lewis
(765) 521-6070 |
Lewis Insurance
1113 Broad St
New Castle, IN |
|
| (765) 529-8993 |
Baldock Hayes Insurance
200 N 12th St
New Castle, IN |
|
Ted Norris
(765) 529-7403 |
Ted Norris Insurance
710 S 14th St
New Castle, IN |
|
Seth Stevens
(765) 529-0002 |
Chapin-Hayworth Insurance
201 N 12th St
New Castle, IN |
http://www.chapinhayworth... |
Joshua P Estelle
(765) 529-6400 |
Pfenninger Insurance Incorporated
1220 Broad St
New Castle, IN |
http://pfenningeragency.c... |
Bruce Winningham
(765) 529-9722 |
Bruce Winningham Insurance
301 S 17th St
New Castle, IN |
|
| (765) 529-1000 |
Farm Bureau Insurance
1702 Indiana Ave
New Castle, IN |
http://www.infarmbureau.c... |
Jim Lowery
(765) 529-1257 |
Shelter Insurance
1004 Broad St # 1
New Castle, IN |
|
| (765) 529-1257 |
Shelter Insurance
1004 Broad St
New Castle, IN |
http://www.shelterinsuran... |
Jane Petty
(765) 529-5744 |
Petty Insurance
702 Broad St
New Castle, IN |
|
Brady Tramel
(765) 529-0336 |
Firemark Insurance
703 Broad St
New Castle, IN |
|
Duane Tramel
(765) 529-0336 |
Firemark Insurance
703 Broad St
New Castle, IN |
|
| (765) 529-3680 |
Farmers Insurance Group
2025 Grand Ave
New Castle, IN |
http://www.farmers.com/ |
| (765) 593-0838 |
Gene Petty Insurance
702 Broad St
New Castle, IN |
|
| (765) 593-0588 |
Gysin Insurance
623 S 21st St
New Castle, IN |
|
Melanie Baker
(765) 521-4181 |
Baker Insurance
536 N Memorial Dr
New Castle, IN |
|
Kim Ondras
(765) 521-4181 |
Baker Insurance
536 N Memorial Dr
New Castle, IN |
|
Mark Baker
(765) 521-4181 |
Baker Insurance
536 N Memorial Dr
New Castle, IN |
|
| (765) 521-4181 |
Baker Insurance Agency
536 N Memorial Dr
New Castle, IN |
|
| (765) 593-5130 |
Star Insurance
403 Parkview Dr
New Castle, IN |
http://www.pekininsurance... |
| (765) 529-0185 |
Shelter Insurance
1817 S Memorial Dr
New Castle, IN |
http://www.shelterinsuran... |
Janet Begley
(765) 529-0707 |
Allstate Insurance
1824 Bundy Ave
New Castle, IN |
|
Leon Seely
(765) 529-0185 |
Shelter Insurance
1817 S Memorial Dr
New Castle, IN |
|
| (765) 521-4530 |
Koontz Insurance and Financial Services
309 Parkview Dr
New Castle, IN |
http://www.erieinsurance.... |
| (765) 529-5049 |
Ameriana Insurance Agency
1908 Bundy Ave
New Castle, IN |
|
Todd Thalls
(765) 529-5049 |
Ameriana Insurance Agency Incorporated
1908 Bundy Ave
New Castle, IN |
|
Cathy Crabtree
(765) 529-5049 |
Ameriana Insurance Incorporated
1908 Bundy Ave
New Castle, IN |
http://amerianainsurance.... |
Mike Thalls
(765) 529-5049 |
Ameriana Insurance Incorporated
1908 Bundy Ave
New Castle, IN |
|
Ed Grant
(765) 529-7010 |
State Farm Insurance
3130 S 14th St
New Castle, IN |
|
Steve Foreman
(765) 529-1000 |
Farm Bureau Insurance
151 Wittenbreaker Ave # A
New Castle, IN |
http://www.infarmbureau.c... |
Bill Baker
(765) 521-4181 |
Baker Agency
536 N Memorial Dr
New Castle, IN |
|
| (765) 593-1111 |
Indiana Title Insurance Company
1319 Indiana Ave
New Castle, IN |
|
| (765) 987-7069 |
Wausau Insurance
3233 S Greensboro Pike
New Castle, IN |
|
| (765) 529-2751 |
Donnell Fred Ins
210 S Main St
New Castle, IN |
|
| (765) 529-1977 |
Cancer Society of Henry Incorporated
1022 Riley Rd
New Castle, IN |
|
| (765) 529-7010 |
Grant Ed
3130 S 14th St
New Castle, IN |
|
| (765) 766-6330 |
Haylor Freyer & Coon Incorporated
5589 E Us Hwy 36
New Castle, IN |
|
| (765) 529-8992 |
Aflac
200 N 12th St
New Castle, IN |
http://www.aflac.com/ |
| (765) 529-0872 |
A Bail Bonds
200 N 12th St
New Castle, IN |
|
| (765) 529-7401 |
Indianapolis Life Insurance Company
3337 S State Road 3
New Castle, IN |
|
Ralph W Keesing
(765) 593-0327 |
Primerica Financial Service
700 S Memorial Dr
New Castle, IN |
http://www.primerica.com/ |
| (765) 529-0707 |
Ashby Jackie
1824 Bundy Ave
New Castle, IN |
|
| (765) 521-0818 |
Koontz & Lewis Incorporated
309 Parkview Dr
New Castle, IN |
|
Gary Thornhill
(765) 529-3030 |
Associated Agencies
2011 Bundy Ave Ste 4
New Castle, IN |
|
Everett Cole
(765) 529-3030 |
Associated Agencies
2011 Bundy Ave Ste 4
New Castle, IN |
http://associatedagencies... |
| (765) 529-8171 |
Donnell Fred Ins
900 Maplewood Dr
New Castle, IN |
|
| (765) 529-9333 |
Grant Ed Ins
2729 N State Road 103
New Castle, IN |
|
| (765) 533-1000 |
Sentry Insurance
108 Bluebird Ln
Sulphur Springs, IN |
|
Casey Kemerly
(765) 533-1000 |
Chase Insurance
108 Bluebird Ln
Sulphur Springs, IN |
|
| (765) 766-5225 |
Associates Insurance Company
5589 E State Road 36
Mooreland, IN |
|
| (765) 478-3865 |
American Family Insurance- Leo V Henderson Agency
40 E Main St
Cambridge City, IN |
http://www.amfam.com/agen... |
