Get Your
Quote Now!
 
Enter Your Zip Code to Get
Auto Insurance Web Quote
 

New Buffalo, MI Car Insurance Rates

New Buffalo, MI Car Insurance Rates

Looking for low cost auto insurance in your town? Either fill out the quote form above or call one of your local agents below. The quote form will allow you to compare rates more quickly in your zip code. If you need assistance please contact us and we will help you find savings for your unique auto situation.

Contact Company Website
(269) 469-6377 Homolka Financial & Insurance Services
139 N Whittaker St
New Buffalo, MI
Dan Donnelly
(269) 469-4438
Peoples Insurance Incorporated
9 W Mechanic St
New Buffalo, MI
(269) 469-4438 Peoples Insurance Agency Incorporated
9 W Mechanic St
New Buffalo, MI
Sherri Kerhoulas
(269) 469-1550
Kerhoulas Insurance
627 W Buffalo St # 1
New Buffalo, MI
Ted Kerhoulas
(269) 469-1550
Kerhoulas Insurance
627 W Buffalo St # 1
New Buffalo, MI
Mike Kerhoulas
(269) 469-1550
Kerhoulas Insurance
627 W Buffalo St # 1
New Buffalo, MI
Tom Rossman
(269) 469-4442
Tom Rossman Insurance
815 E Buffalo St
New Buffalo, MI
http://statefarm.com/
(269) 469-5109 Insurance Management Service
1511 E Buffalo St
New Buffalo, MI
(269) 469-4780 Chicago Title Insurance Company
207 N Whittaker St
New Buffalo, MI
Ed Homolka
(269) 469-6377
Homolka Financial & INS Service
139 N Whittaker St
New Buffalo, MI
(269) 469-1550 Michael T Kerhoulas Incorporated
627 W Buffalo St # 1
New Buffalo, MI
Ken Thomasson
(269) 469-8888
New Buffalo Agency
3 W Buffalo St
New Buffalo, MI
(269) 469-8888 New Buffalo Agency
3 W Buffalo St
New Buffalo, MI
http://www.newbuffaloins....
David Hoffman
(269) 469-0100
Hoffman Benefit Group Incorporated
105 W Merchant St
New Buffalo, MI
Mary Lou Johnson
(269) 469-3244
Johnson Insurance
10234 Community Hall Rd
Union Pier, MI
Kevin L Snyder
(219) 874-7434
Snyder Insurance
1905 Franklin St
Michigan City, MI
http://www.snyderinsuranc...
(219) 879-5357 Allstate Insurance Companies
1812 E Us Highway 20
Michigan City, MI
http://agent.allstate.com...
(219) 861-0930 Affordable Insurance Agency
1802 E Us Highway 20
Michigan City, MI
http://www.driveaffordabl...
John Klingenmeier
(219) 879-6482
Michiana Insurance Service
5835 N Johnson Rd
Michigan City, MI
(219) 879-4581 General Insurance Services Incorporated
421 Franklin St
Michigan City, MI
Linda Mc Kinney
(219) 878-1878
Allstate Insurance Company
116 W 10th St
Michigan City, MI
http://agent.allstate.com...
(269) 756-3977 New Buffalo Insurance Agency
6761 Us Highway 12
Three Oaks, MI
Jodi Haughey
(269) 756-3977
New Buffalo Insurance
6761 Us Highway 12
Three Oaks, MI
(269) 756-9564 Harbor Country Insurance Agency
11 N Elm St
Three Oaks, MI
http://www.harborcountry....
Gregory Bubb
(269) 756-9564
Harbor Country Insurance
11 N Elm St
Three Oaks, MI
(574) 654-7055 Insurance Benefits Counseling Incorporated
105 Michigan St W
Three Oaks, MI
Tim Stevenson
(269) 756-9558
Farm Bureau Insurance
18 S Elm St
Three Oaks, MI
(269) 756-9558 Farm Bureau Insurance
18 S Elm St
Three Oaks, MI
http://www.infarmbureau.c...
(219) 879-4524 Dolson Insurance Agency
450 Saint John Rd
Michigan City, MI
Dave Majerek
(269) 756-9567
Dave Majerek Insurance
21 N Elm St Ste 3
Three Oaks, MI
(574) 654-3223 Barnhart Insurance Agency Incorporated
136 Michigan St E
Three Oaks, MI
Craig Mc Donald
(219) 362-2434
Craig Mc Donald Insurance
2434 N State Road 39
Laporte, MI
(219) 324-9595 Allstate Insurance Companies
2334 N Us Highway 35
Laporte, MI
http://agent.allstate.com...
(219) 324-5338 Farmers Insurance Group
181 E 600 N
Laporte, MI
http://www.farmers.com/
(219) 326-1685 Keiser Insurance
405 State St
La Porte, MI
(219) 324-0121 American Family Insurance- Michelle Mullins-Land Agency
610 Jefferson Ave
La Porte, MI
http://www.amfam.com/agen...
Debbie Blake
(219) 362-5253
Blake Insurance Incorporated
1405 E Lincolnway
Laporte, MI
http://blakeins.com/
David Strefling
(269) 465-3433
Strefling Insurance Incorporated
4488 Lake St
Bridgman, MI
(269) 465-6222 Liskey Insurance
4263 Lake St
Bridgman, MI
(269) 469-9236 Farmers Insurance Group
13213 Red Arrow Hwy
Sawyer, MI
http://www.farmers.com/
(219) 362-2113 General Insurance Services Incorporated
1200 Michigan Ave
Laporte, MI
Jim Eriksson
(219) 874-6360
State Farm Insurance
405 Johnson Rd
Trail Creek, MI
Roger Sill
(219) 872-0607
Farm Bureau Insurance
5416 N Johnson Rd
Michigan City, MI
http://infarmbureau.com/
Jim Mc Nallan
(219) 879-6482
Michiana Insurance
5385 N Johnson Rd
Michigan City, MI
John Jones
(219) 879-6482
Michiana Insurance
5385 N Johnson Rd
Michigan City, MI
AL Kepler
(219) 879-6482
Michiana Insurance Service
5385 N Johnson Rd
Michigan City, MI
(219) 872-0607 Farm Bureau Insurance
5416 N Johnson Rd
Michigan City, MI
http://www.infarmbureau.c...
(219) 874-4256 State Farm Insurance
1902 E Us Highway 20
Michigan City, MI
http://www.statefarm.com/
(219) 874-2231 Geyer Insurance Services LLC
4511 N Johnson Rd
Michigan City, MI
Larry Joyner
(219) 879-5357
Allstate Insurance Company
1812 E Us Highway 20
Michigan City, MI
Warren J Attar
(219) 874-4256
State Farm Insurance
1902 E Us Highway 20
Michigan City, MI
Tim Davis
(219) 861-0930
Affordable Insurance
1802 E Us Highway 20
Michigan City, MI
(219) 872-9103 Ticor Title Insurance
522 Franklin St
Michigan City, MI
Don Ramsey
(219) 879-4422
Horace Mann Insurance Company
6791 W Magnolia Ave
Michigan City, MI
(219) 879-4422 Horace Mann Insurance
6791 W Magnolia Ave
Michigan City, MI
http://www.horacemann.com...
Dan Nole
(219) 879-4581
General Insurance Svc Incorporated
421 Franklin St
Michigan City, MI
Sharon Miles
(219) 879-4581
General Insurance Svc Incorporated
421 Franklin St
Michigan City, MI
Steve Jacox
(219) 879-4581
General Insurance Svc Incorporated
421 Franklin St
Michigan City, MI
Art Kemp
(219) 879-4581
General Insurance Svc Incorporated
421 Franklin St
Michigan City, MI
Tom A Keene
(219) 879-4581
General Insurance Svc Incorporated
421 Franklin St
Michigan City, MI

 
Customers say...
I spoke with my agent from ***** who said I probably wouldn't save much, so instead, I went straight home after picking up the kids from school, jumped on to AutoInsuranceWeb.com, and in a few short minutes, found that I could save about $40 a month by switching insurance companies. I think I'm going to save a few $1,000 dollars over the next few years. Gosh! My agent is terrible. I owe you a big one :)

Kimara