Get Your
Quote Now!
 
Enter Your Zip Code to Get
Auto Insurance Web Quote
 

Elma, NY Car Insurance Rates

Elma, NY Car Insurance Rates

Looking for low cost auto insurance in your town? Either fill out the quote form above or call one of your local agents below. The quote form will allow you to compare rates more quickly in your zip code. If you need assistance please contact us and we will help you find savings for your unique auto situation.

Contact Company Website
Mike Janiga
(716) 655-5900
Farm Family Insurance Company
7000 Seneca St
Elma, NY
Jack Coy
(716) 652-6090
Jack Coy Agency Incorporated
2331 Bowen Rd
Elma, NY
John Simme
(716) 652-6469
Metro Simme Agency
2330 Bowen Rd
Elma, NY
(716) 681-9420 Allstate Insurance Companies
5874 Transit Rd
Depew, NY
http://agent.allstate.com...
Paul Juftinger
(716) 683-2130
Nickel City Insurance
5532 Broadway St
Lancaster, NY
http://nickelcityins.com/
(716) 668-5100 Allstate Insurance Company
1282 French Rd
Depew, NY
http://agent.allstate.com...
Paul Chrzanowski
(716) 681-9420
Allstate Insurance Company
5874 Transit Rd
Depew, NY
(716) 681-2845 Allstate Insurance Companies
3725 Walden Ave
Lancaster, NY
http://agent.allstate.com...
Jay Blatchley
(716) 675-5015
Blatchley Insurance
4185 Seneca St Ste 5
West Seneca, NY
http://bassociates.biz/
Greg Horwitz
(716) 668-7757
Buffalo Niagara Insurance
2157 Union Rd
West Seneca, NY
http://agent.allstate.com...
William Hourigan
(716) 681-5225
Allstate Insurance Company
2304 George Urban Blvd
Depew, NY
http://agent.allstate.com...
(716) 656-0500 State Farm Insurance
4731 Transit Rd
Depew, NY
http://www.statefarm.com/
Anita B Lesmond
(716) 656-0500
State Farm Insurance
4729 Transit Rd # 2
Depew, NY
(716) 683-2130 Nickel City Insurance Agency Incorporated
5532 Broadway St
Lancaster, NY
http://www.nickelcityins....
Kathy Miller
(716) 656-8008
Nationwide Insurance
1276 French Rd
Depew, NY
(716) 675-8100 Allstate Insurance Companies
3346 Southwestern Blvd
Orchard Park, NY
http://agent.allstate.com...
Michael Huber
(716) 668-5100
Allstate Insurance
1282 French Rd
Depew, NY
http://www.allstate.com/
(716) 683-6350 United Insurance
(716) 683-6350
David W Friend
(716) 686-0840
Allstate Insurance Company
5150 Broadway
Depew, NY
(716) 681-6664 State Farm Insurance
4981 Broadway
Depew, NY
http://www.statefarm.com/
(716) 893-1713 Blatchley Insurance
3022 Genesee St
Cheektowaga, NY
(716) 684-9876 Allstate Insurance Companies
3800 Union Rd
Cheektowaga, NY
http://agent.allstate.com...
Dan Scaglione
(716) 668-4088
State Farm Insurance
928 French Rd # A
Cheektowaga, NY
Robert E Doyle
(716) 681-6664
State Farm Insurance
4981 Broadway
Depew, NY
Craig Willoughby
(716) 827-0500
Willoughby Insurance
1994 Seneca St
Buffalo, NY
http://www.willoughbyinsu...
Dan Scaglione
(716) 668-4088
Dan Scaglione Insurance
928 French Rd # A
Cheektowaga, NY
Joseph S Krieger
(716) 897-1109
Allstate Insurance Company
1560 Harlem Rd Ste 2
Buffalo, NY
http://agent.allstate.com...
(716) 677-2734 Liberty Mutual Insurance Company
1100 Southwestern Blvd Ste 180
Buffalo, NY
http://www.libertymutual....
Bill Walters
(716) 681-2845
Allstate Insurance Company
3725 Walden Ave
Lancaster, NY
Roger Malcolm
(716) 839-0788
Mutual of Omaha Insurance Company
6245 Sheridan Dr Ste 108
Buffalo, NY
(716) 675-2069 Martin Shaughnessy Insurance
3 Kelly Dr
Cheektowaga, NY
Christopher Majchrzak
(716) 681-3444
State Farm Insurance
3132 Walden Ave
Depew, NY
(716) 685-9594 Colonial Insurance
440 Columbia Ave
Depew, NY
(716) 759-1600 Allstate Insurance Company
10070 Main St
Clarence, NY
http://agent.allstate.com...
(716) 681-3444 State Farm Insurance
3132 Walden Ave
Depew, NY
http://www.statefarm.com/
(716) 937-3233 Jellison Insurance Agency
11861 Broadway St
Alden, NY
http://www.jellisonhart.c...
Thomas J Seelig
(716) 683-6634
Nationwide Insurance
5905 Transit Rd
Depew, NY
(716) 684-5700 Willoughby Insurance
6043 Transit Rd
Depew, NY
http://willoughbyinsuranc...
Nancy Hart
(716) 937-7003
Jellison-Hart Insurance
11861 Broadway St
Alden, NY
(716) 631-9140 Liberty Mutual Insurance Company
325 Essjay Rd Ste 210
Buffalo, NY
http://www.libertymutual....
Art Stover
(716) 675-2000
Art Stover Insurance
4184 Seneca St
Buffalo, NY
(716) 655-3070 State Farm Insurance
628 Main St
East Aurora, NY
http://www.statefarm.com/
Wallace Weigel
(716) 652-1420
Crawford Insurance Service
653 Main St
East Aurora, NY
(716) 675-5171 Great American Insurance Company
101 Hunters Ridge Rd
Orchard Park, NY
Richard Schunke
(716) 675-5008
Schunke Insurance
997 Union Rd
West Seneca, NY
http://anarmoragent.com/
Jeremiah J Sheehy
(716) 668-4616
Nationwide Insurance
2177 Union Rd
West Seneca, NY
(716) 668-4616 Nationwide Insurance
2177 Union Rd
West Seneca, NY
Barbara Gingerich
(716) 652-5151
Farm Bureau Insurance
21 S Grove St Ste 260
East Aurora, NY
(716) 675-5075 Jem Insurance
950 Union Rd
West Seneca, NY
http://www.jeminsurance.c...
William J Hubert
(716) 655-3070
State Farm Insurance
628 Main St
East Aurora, NY
Tom Larsen
(716) 684-3203
Larsen Insurance Association
6351 Transit Rd
Depew, NY
http://www.nyrestaurantin...
(716) 675-5996 Besrate Insurance
997 Union Rd
West Seneca, NY
(716) 652-3440 Agri Business Brokerage Corporation Insurance
417 Quaker Rd
East Aurora, NY
http://www.lunser.com/
Judy Stockman
(716) 674-7274
Enb Insurance Incorporated
938 Union Rd
West Seneca, NY
(716) 204-4000 Metlife Insurance Company
7854 Transit Rd Ste 1
Williamsville, NY
http://www.metlife.com/
Jill Sinclair
(716) 675-5075
Jem Insurance
950 Union Rd # 16a
West Seneca, NY
http://jeminsurance.com/
(716) 631-9140 Liberty Mutual Insurance Buffalo, NY
325 Essjay Rd Ste 210
Buffalo, NY
http://www.libertymutual....
(716) 635-0594 Allstate Insurance Company
425 Essjay Rd
Williamsville, NY
http://agent.allstate.com...
(716) 631-3000 Allstate Insurance Company
5150 Main St
Williamsville, NY
http://agent.allstate.com...
Kimberly Heary
(716) 652-9700
Heary Allstate Insurance Company
250 Quaker Rd
East Aurora, NY

 
Customers say...
I spoke with my agent from ***** who said I probably wouldn't save much, so instead, I went straight home after picking up the kids from school, jumped on to AutoInsuranceWeb.com, and in a few short minutes, found that I could save about $40 a month by switching insurance companies. I think I'm going to save a few $1,000 dollars over the next few years. Gosh! My agent is terrible. I owe you a big one :)

Kimara