Get Your
Quote Now!
 
Enter Your Zip Code to Get
Auto Insurance Web Quote
 

Middle Island, NY Car Insurance Rates

Middle Island, NY Car Insurance Rates

Looking for low cost auto insurance in your town? Either fill out the quote form above or call one of your local agents below. The quote form will allow you to compare rates more quickly in your zip code. If you need assistance please contact us and we will help you find savings for your unique auto situation.

Contact Company Website
P Kevin Fischer
(631) 345-3276
State Farm Insurance
833 Middle Country Rd
Middle Island, NY
(631) 736-0880 Hermitage Insurance Brokerage
65 Middle Country Rd
Middle Island, NY
http://www.hermitageinsur...
Michael Paluba
(631) 736-0880
Hermitage Insurance Brokerage
65 Middle Country Rd
Middle Island, NY
http://hermitageinsurance...
(631) 205-1900 Start Rite Incorporated
1545 Rocky Point Rd
Middle Island, NY
http://www.startriteinc.c...
P Kevin Fischer
(631) 345-3276
P Kevin Fischer Agency Incorporated
833 Middle Country Rd
Middle Island, NY
(631) 924-2219 Nixx Investigations & Claim
301 Middle Country Rd
Middle Island, NY
(631) 736-3484 Sullivan Agency Incorporated
44 Middle Country Rd
Middle Island, NY
Bruce Schneider
(631) 698-3558
Bruce Schneider Association
45 Middle Country Rd
Middle Island, NY
http://bvsainsurance.com/
Maryann Trapani
(631) 696-4400
M & M Agency
16 Middle Country Rd
Middle Island, NY
(631) 736-3100 Allstate Insurance Companies
35 Middle Country Rd Ste D
Coram, NY
http://agent.allstate.com...
(631) 331-7196 Liberty Mutual Insurance Company
451 Route 25a
Miller Place, NY
http://www.libertymutual....
(631) 821-3311 Allstate Insurance Company
538 Route 25a Ste A
Rocky Point, NY
http://agent.allstate.com...
(631) 736-7100 Allstate Insurance Companies
248 Middle Country Rd # 260
Selden, NY
http://agent.allstate.com...
(631) 821-4300 Allstate Insurance Companies
691 Route 25a
Miller Place, NY
http://agent.allstate.com...
(631) 451-0477 Excel Insurance Incorporated
280 Middle Country Rd
Selden, NY
Abby Alhante
(631) 698-2777
Dcap Insurance
2890 Route 112 # A
Medford, NY
http://www.dcapinsurance....
(631) 654-5454 Apple Insurance
1070 Middle Country Rd
Selden, NY
http://www.gmacinsurance....
(631) 395-0955 Allstate Insurance Companies
246 Moriches Middle Island Rd
Manorville, NY
http://agent.allstate.com...
Robert Safford
(631) 736-3100
Allstate Insurance Company
35 Middle Country Rd Ste D
Coram, NY
Robert Randell
(631) 736-2820
Allstate Insurance Company
1305 Middle Country Rd Ste 15
Selden, NY
(631) 698-4776 Cotten Coverage Insurance
530 Horseblock Rd
Farmingville, NY
http://www.cottencoverage...
Israel Caraballo
(631) 289-8700
Allstate Insurance Company
2265 Route 112 # C
Medford, NY
http://agent.allstate.com...
(631) 732-8700 Allstate Insurance Companies
910 Middle Country Rd
Selden, NY
http://agent.allstate.com...
Christopher Stathis
(631) 654-5454
Apple Insurance
1070 Middle Country Rd Ste 4b
Selden, NY
(631) 474-2020 Allstate Insurance Companies
1165 Route 112
Port Jefferson Station, NY
http://agent.allstate.com...
(800) 319-4490 Liberty Mutual Insurance Company
4747-28 Nesconset Hwy
Port Jefferson Station, NY
http://www.libertymutual....
(631) 929-3400 Allstate Insurance Company
6278 Route 25a
Wading River, NY
http://agent.allstate.com...
(631) 928-8222 Allstate Insurance Companies
1109 Hallock Ave
Port Jefferson Station, NY
http://agent.allstate.com...
Dennis Skinner
(631) 736-0236
Knights of Columbus Insurance
260 Middle Country Rd # 14
Coram, NY
http://www.kofc.org/
Kevin Cantwell
(631) 696-7353
Farm Family Casualty Insurance
356 Middle Country Rd
Coram, NY
(631) 399-1100 Allstate Insurance Companies
895 Montauk Hwy
Shirley, NY
http://agent.allstate.com...
(631) 286-6000 Allstate Insurance Companies
2470 Montauk Hwy
Brookhaven, NY
http://agent.allstate.com...
(631) 929-6700 Wise, David A-State Farm Insurance Agent
5960 Route 25a
Wading River, NY
http://statefarm.mqgroup....
Richard Dennis
(631) 736-3300
Nu Concept Insurance
3663 Route 112 Ste 9
Coram, NY
(631) 737-0700 Nca Insurance
2201 Route 112
Coram, NY
(631) 698-1831 Consumers Insurance Center
385 Middle Country Rd
Coram, NY
Charles J Bottitta
(631) 698-0651
Consumers Insurance Center
385 Middle Country Rd
Coram, NY
Charlesworth B Varlack Agy Inc
(631) 399-0099
State Farm Insurance Agent
501 William Floyd Pkwy
Shirley, NY
http://statefarm.mqgroup....
H Lincoln Miller
(631) 737-0700
Nca Insurance
2201 Route 112
Coram, NY
http://nysfoplodge25.org/
(631) 732-0040 Safeco Insurance
603 Townehouse Dr
Coram, NY
Anne Marie
(631) 331-4540
Health Insurance Expeditor Service
389 Miller Place Rd
Miller Place, NY
Wj Reynolds
(631) 286-0547
Reynolds & Reynolds Insurance
1700 Montauk Hwy
Bellport, NY
http://reynoldsagency.com...
Eugene A Dicks
(631) 698-1441
State Farm Insurance
1672 Route 112
Coram, NY
Adam M Nedvin
(631) 698-4400
Allstate Insurance Company
1025 Portion Rd Ste A
Farmingville, NY
http://agent.allstate.com...
(631) 758-7225 Allstate Insurance Companies
629 Medford Ave Ste 10
Patchogue, NY
http://agent.allstate.com...
Walter Colleran
(631) 744-9226
Colleran Insurance
333 Route 25a
Rocky Point, NY
(631) 744-1200 Shore Line Insurance Agency
8 Broadway
Rocky Point, NY
http://www.shorelineins.c...
(631) 744-9480 Affordable Insurance Service
856 Route 25a
Miller Place, NY
BART Burlison
(631) 698-7200
Allstate Insurance Company
3138 Route 112
Medford, NY
(631) 246-5200 Allstate Insurance Companies
232 N Belle Mead Rd Ste 8
East Setauket, NY
http://agent.allstate.com...
Douglas A Merrick
(631) 732-4949
Douglas A Merrick Insurance
325 Middle Country Rd Ste 2
Selden, NY
Chris Grzymala
(631) 744-1200
Shore Line Insurance
8 Broadway
Rocky Point, NY
http://shorelineins.com/
James R Stevens
(631) 744-7116
State Farm Insurance
745 Route 25a
Miller Place, NY
http://statefarm.com/
Douglas Norris
(631) 736-7100
Allstate Insurance Company
248 Middle Country Rd
Selden, NY
Frank Vu
(631) 451-0477
Excel Insurance
280 Middle Country Rd Ste F
Selden, NY
(212) 599-2474 Insurance Solutions Group
476 Expressway Dr S
Medford, NY
Doug Carlen
(631) 331-7196
Liberty Mutual Insurance
451 Route 25a
Miller Place, NY
http://www.libertymutuali...
Abby Alhante
(631) 698-0780
D Cap Family Insurance Brkrg
2890 Route 112
Medford, NY

 
Customers say...
I spoke with my agent from ***** who said I probably wouldn't save much, so instead, I went straight home after picking up the kids from school, jumped on to AutoInsuranceWeb.com, and in a few short minutes, found that I could save about $40 a month by switching insurance companies. I think I'm going to save a few $1,000 dollars over the next few years. Gosh! My agent is terrible. I owe you a big one :)

Kimara